Standards
What National Standards Are
Applicable To SPDs?Listing
In the USA, with the exception of utility and rail
industries, all AC power connected SPDs must be installed in
accordance with NEC wiring rules. This requires that the
product be listed for such a purpose. To be
"listed", an SPD must be approved by a Nationally
Accredited Testing Laboratory (NTL). One example of a NTL
listing service is Underwriters Laboratories Inc. (UL).
UL1449 2nd Ed Listed, including the requirements of Feb.
9, 2007
The primary concern of UL is safety. To this end they have
developed a Standard UL 1449 Edition 2 Standard for
Safety, Transient Voltage Surge Suppressors for the
testing of TVSS/SPDs. Under Edition 2 of this Standard, an
SPD is taken through an extensive test regimen to ensure
that it will not pose a safety hazard under normal
operations as well as under potential failure modes, such as
abnormal utility supply events.
UL 1449 is not considered a performance standard, but it
does assign a Suppressed Voltage Rating to the SPD being
tested. To some extent this allows the performance of two
SPDs to be compared, however it is important to note that
this test is conducted at a very low energy level to
accommodate the smaller SPDs on the market. It does not
adequately demonstrate performance for branch and service
entrance products.
A shortcoming of UL 1449 is that it only requires products
to remain operational on voltages up to 110% of nominal.
SPDs are allowed to (safely) permanently fail if voltage
exceeds this. To limit the possibility of frequent SPD
replacements due to TOV, it is recommended that customers
additionally specify that the Maximum Continuous Operating
Voltage be at least 125% of nominal.
It is also important to note
that UL 1449 does not test that an SPD meets the
manufacturers claimed surge rating. While this may appear
a severe oversight on the part of the Standard, it becomes
more understandable when we consider that the primary
concern of UL is safety and not performance. The onus is
left to the customer to seek from the SPD manufacturer,
evidence supporting claimed surge ratings. This may be
provided in the form of in-house test results or preferably
independent third party test certificates.
ANSI/IEEE C62.41
In addition to considering the SVR figure provided for an
SPD under UL 1449, customers should also request let-through
voltages in accordance with ANSI/IEEE C62.41 Location
categories A3 & B3 Ringwaves and B3 & C3 Combination
waves. This will test the SPD's clamping performance with
currents up to 10kA 8/20µs.
ANSI/IEEE C62.45
Compliance with life cycle testing in accordance with
ANSI/IEEE C62.45 should also be requested. This will ensure
that products have been tested with at least 10-1000
sequential impulses.
NEMA Standards Publication No. LS1 Low Voltage Surge
Protective Devices
NEMA Standards Publication No. LS1 "Low Voltage Surge
Protective Devices" defines a method of specifying SPD
performance. Potential customers wishing to compare the
relative performance of SPDs should require that all data
and specification sheets be supplied in NEMA LS1 format.
An important requirement under NEMA LS1 is that the claimed
surge rating of an SPD be based on tested results and not
simply extrapolated or theoretical values. This requirement
ensures that the SPD's surge rating is what it has
demonstrated it can withstand, and is not simply based on
the aggregate surge rating of MOV material. This type of
testing truly exercises all aspects of the SPD design
including important criteria such as the ability of the
terminals and PCB tracks to handle the claimed current
rating. It is not uncommon in the unregulated market of SPDs,
to find products that claim certain ratings but use internal
series fuses that will rupture at levels well below those
claimed for the device. All too often, claimed ratings are
based on the aggregate of MOVs or extrapolations of testing
portions of parallel circuits at lower amplitude |